The most crucial Dallas Cowboys contract that needs renewal is that of Will McClay, the team’s Vice President of Player Personnel. While there are several contracts up for renewal, McClay’s is arguably the most important for the long-term success of the team. His expertise and influence in scouting and drafting players have been key to the Cowboys’ recent success, and retaining him is vital for maintaining that success moving forward.
Will McClay has been a part of the Dallas Cowboys organization since 2002, starting as a regular scout. Over time, he has ascended through the ranks to become one of the NFL’s top talent evaluators. He became the team’s VP of Player Personnel in 2017, and since then, his impact on the roster has been undeniable. McClay has played a pivotal role in identifying and drafting top talent, including numerous Pro Bowl players and All-Pros.
Despite Jerry Jones, the owner of the Cowboys, making the final decisions on all team matters, McClay is the one who ensures the team selects the right players for its needs. He has a remarkable track record, having identified 16 Pro Bowl players, which is the most in the NFL during his tenure. McClay’s success includes building a dominant offensive line and finding stars like Micah Parsons, who has become a key player on the Cowboys’ defense.
More recently, McClay’s ability to spot talent has continued to shine. He signed KaVontae Turpin and Brandon Aubrey, former USFL players, who both made the Pro Bowl in 2024. This further highlights McClay’s knack for identifying under-the-radar players who can make an immediate impact at the highest level, reinforcing why the Cowboys should prioritize renewing his contract.
The Cowboys must not delay in securing McClay’s future with the team. His ability to find and develop talent has been invaluable, and there’s no reason to let him walk away. Despite McClay’s importance to the team, the Cowboys have been quiet about his contract situation, which raises concerns. Jerry Jones has made it clear that he plans to address team weaknesses through the draft rather than relying heavily on free-agent signings, making McClay’s continued involvement in the draft process even more critical.
The uncertainty surrounding McClay’s future could have dire consequences for the Cowboys’ upcoming seasons. With the team facing several roster needs, including bolstering the offense and defensive line, keeping McClay is crucial to executing a successful draft. Without McClay’s expertise, the Cowboys risk a disastrous draft that could significantly hinder their chances in 2025, especially if they are unable to secure the necessary pieces for a championship-caliber team.
While Jerry Jones will also need to make decisions about the coaching staff, including the future of the head coach position, the draft holds greater significance in the Cowboys’ rebuilding efforts. The team already has key players like Dak Prescott and CeeDee Lamb, but they need more talent across the roster to become serious contenders. McClay’s ability to identify the right players is essential in ensuring the Cowboys can address their weaknesses and strengthen key positions, such as offensive weapons and defensive tackle.
Ultimately, the Cowboys need to keep Will McClay to ensure the success of their upcoming seasons. Whether they are looking to add offensive depth, improve the run game, or solidify the defense, McClay’s draft acumen is vital for making those improvements. Losing McClay would be a devastating blow to the Cowboys’ chances of competing at a high level in the near future, and Jerry Jones must prioritize securing his future with the organization.
