With the NFL trade deadline on the horizon, analysts and former executives are speculating about bold moves that
With the NFL trade deadline on the horizon, analysts and former executives are speculating about bold moves that teams could make to strengthen their rosters.
A recent proposal has drawn interest from Detroit Lions fans for both its ambition and its steep price. Former NFL general manager Mike Tannenbaum has suggested a blockbuster trade that would bring Cleveland Browns star pass rusher, Myles Garrett, to Detroit.
Tannenbaum’s proposal involves the Lions parting with a huge package in return for Garrett. According to the details shown, the Lions would acquire Myles Garrett, one of the league’s top defensive players, in exchange for three first-round picks, a second-round pick, and standout running back Jahmyr Gibbs.
The Trade Proposal: A Significant Investment Here’s Tannenbaum’s full trade suggestion:
Detroit Lions receive: DE Myles Garrett Cleveland Browns receive: Three first-round picks, a second-round pick, and RB Jahmyr Gibbs
This potential trade has sparked intense debate among fans and analysts. For Detroit, it would be a massive investment in their defense, adding an elite pass rusher to a team currently dealing with injuries on the defensive line. Garrett, a three-time Pro Bowler and one of the NFL’s top pass rushers, could immediately elevate Detroit’s defense, giving them a chance to compete deep into the playoffs.
However, the cost is extremely high. Giving up three first-round picks would drain the Lions’ future draft assets and reduce their flexibility in building the roster over the next few years. Including Jahmyr Gibbs—an exceptionally talented running back—adds even more weight to the deal.
Why Tannenbaum Thinks It Makes Sense Known for his bold ideas, Tannenbaum appears to believe that the Lions are just a few pieces away from becoming Super Bowl contenders. Adding Garrett, he argues, would bolster Detroit’s defense, especially with Aidan Hutchinson likely out for the season. Garrett’s addition would provide an instant boost to Detroit’s pass rush, enhancing their Super Bowl prospects.
According to Tannenbaum, the Lions are uniquely positioned to win now, and adding a star like Garrett could give them the edge to compete with top teams, including the reigning champion Kansas City Chiefs. However, he acknowledges the hefty price tag, suggesting the Lions must decide if they’re ready to sacrifice future assets for a “win-now” approach.
Fan Reaction: Is the Trade Worth It? Tannenbaum’s proposal has received a mixed reaction. Some Lions fans are excited by the prospect of building an elite defense, but many are hesitant to sacrifice so much draft capital, especially given Detroit’s recent drafting success under GM Brad Holmes. Gibbs, in particular, is a promising young player, and losing him would be difficult.
Additionally, the Lions are focused on building a sustainable team with depth and youth, and sacrificing future assets could be seen as a risky gamble that may not yield long-term rewards.
Bottom Line: An Unlikely but Intriguing Trade
While adding a player like Myles Garrett is certainly tempting for Lions fans, Tannenbaum’s proposed trade seems extreme. Detroit’s front office has been patient and strategic, prioritizing draft picks and young talent over flashy moves. Trading three first-round picks, a second-round pick, and a standout like Gibbs might simply be too much to ask—even for a player of Garrett’s quality.
As the trade deadline nears, it will be interesting to see if the Lions make any moves to strengthen their roster. For now, fans can debate whether a huge, all-in trade for Myles Garrett would be worth the cost or if Detroit should stay the course and focus on long-term success.
teams could make to strengthen their rosters.
A recent proposal has drawn interest from Detroit Lions fans for both its ambition and its steep price. Former NFL general manager Mike Tannenbaum has suggested a blockbuster trade that would bring Cleveland Browns star pass rusher, Myles Garrett, to Detroit.
Tannenbaum’s proposal involves the Lions parting with a huge package in return for Garrett. According to the details shown, the Lions would acquire Myles Garrett, one of the league’s top defensive players, in exchange for three first-round picks, a second-round pick, and standout running back Jahmyr Gibbs.
The Trade Proposal: A Significant Investment Here’s Tannenbaum’s full trade suggestion:
Detroit Lions receive: DE Myles Garrett Cleveland Browns receive: Three first-round picks, a second-round pick, and RB Jahmyr Gibbs
This potential trade has sparked intense debate among fans and analysts. For Detroit, it would be a massive investment in their defense, adding an elite pass rusher to a team currently dealing with injuries on the defensive line.
Garrett, a three-time Pro Bowler and one of the NFL’s top pass rushers, could immediately elevate Detroit’s defense, giving them a chance to compete deep into the playoffs.
However, the cost is extremely high. Giving up three first-round picks would drain the Lions’ future draft assets and reduce their flexibility in building the roster over the next few years. Including Jahmyr Gibbs—an exceptionally talented running back—adds even more weight to the deal.
Why Tannenbaum Thinks It Makes Sense Known for his bold ideas, Tannenbaum appears to believe that the Lions are just a few pieces away from becoming Super Bowl contenders.
Adding Garrett, he argues, would bolster Detroit’s defense, especially with Aidan Hutchinson likely out for the season. Garrett’s addition would provide an instant boost to Detroit’s pass rush, enhancing their Super Bowl prospects.
According to Tannenbaum, the Lions are uniquely positioned to win now, and adding a star like Garrett could give them the edge to compete with top teams, including the reigning champion Kansas City Chiefs.
However, he acknowledges the hefty price tag, suggesting the Lions must decide if they’re ready to sacrifice future assets for a “win-now” approach.
Fan Reaction: Is the Trade Worth It? Tannenbaum’s proposal has received a mixed reaction. Some Lions fans are excited by the prospect of building an elite defense, but many are hesitant to sacrifice so much draft capital, especially given Detroit’s recent drafting success under GM Brad Holmes. Gibbs, in particular, is a promising young player, and losing him would be difficult.
Additionally, the Lions are focused on building a sustainable team with depth and youth, and sacrificing future assets could be seen as a risky gamble that may not yield long-term rewards.
Bottom Line: An Unlikely but Intriguing Trade
While adding a player like Myles Garrett is certainly tempting for Lions fans, Tannenbaum’s proposed trade seems extreme. Detroit’s front office has been patient and strategic, prioritizing draft picks and young talent over flashy moves. Trading three first-round picks, a second-round pick, and a standout like Gibbs might simply be too much to ask—even for a player of Garrett’s quality.
As the trade deadline nears, it will be interesting to see if the Lions make any moves to strengthen their roster. For now, fans can debate whether a huge, all-in trade for Myles Garrett would be worth the cost or if Detroit should stay the course and focus on long-term success.
