Stephen A. Smith, known for his bold takes on ESPN’s First Take, has once again sparked debate with his list of top five NFL teams through Week 9.
His lineup includes some expected powerhouses, but he’s also made a few surprising selections that have raised eyebrows. Here’s a closer look at his choices and why each team might deserve their spot.
1. Detroit Lions
Putting the Detroit Lions at number one may have shocked some, but they’ve earned their place among the NFL’s best teams this season. Led by quarterback Jared Goff, the Lions are showing resilience and skill, dominating both offensively and defensively.
Dan Campbell’s coaching has transformed them into a well-rounded unit, and the team’s young talent—particularly on defense—has been impressive. This ranking signals that the Lions’ era as an underdog could be shifting toward genuine contention.
2. Kansas City Chiefs
The Chiefs being high on the list is hardly surprising. Reigning Super Bowl champions, Kansas City continues to showcase their powerhouse offense and revamped defense.
Despite some ups and downs on offense due to new receiving corps, Patrick Mahomes has kept them competitive, and their defense has stepped up significantly this season. They’re not only contenders but also remain the team to beat in the AFC.
3. Buffalo Bills
Buffalo’s inclusion is a bit controversial, considering they’ve been inconsistent. While Josh Allen and the Bills have the potential to dominate any team, their recent struggles raise questions about their place in the top five. Still,
Stephen A. is likely banking on their potential and explosive offense, which has shown the capability to blow out opponents. If they can find consistency, they could be a playoff force.
4. Baltimore Ravens
The Ravens’ recent performances have impressed analysts, and they’re becoming a clear contender. With Lamar Jackson healthy and the offense humming under new offensive coordinator Todd Monken,
Baltimore has shown remarkable depth. Their defense is formidable, making them a balanced and dangerous team that’s hard to stop.
5. Washington Commanders
Perhaps the most surprising choice on this list, Washington has been gritty under head coach Ron Rivera. Despite lacking star power, they’ve managed some big wins and are competitive, particularly on defense. They’re not often considered among the NFL’s elite, but Smith’s pick suggests he sees potential for them to upset stronger teams.
Stephen A.’s list isn’t without controversy, but it captures the NFL’s unpredictable nature this season. While not everyone may agree, his picks highlight the teams he believes are poised for success as we enter the season’s second half.
