In 2023, the Detroit Lions dealt with a struggling pass defense, ranking among the worst in the NFL. To address this, general manager Brad Holmes prioritized improving the secondary, including acquiring veteran cornerback Carlton Davis in a trade with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
While Davis brought some steadiness, his performance has fallen short of expectations. He has allowed a 65.2% completion rate and a passer rating of 99.3, trailing behind rookie Terrion Arnold’s impressive 56.5% completion rate and 91.8 passer rating.
These underwhelming stats suggest Davis may not be part of Detroit’s long-term strategy, especially with Arnold emerging and Ennis Rakestraw Jr. awaiting his chance. Given the Lions’ probable reluctance to meet Davis’ contract demands, the 27-year-old may need to find a new team next season.
According to Bleacher Report’s Scouting Department, the Pittsburgh Steelers could be a potential destination for Davis. Pittsburgh has a standout cornerback in Joey Porter Jr., whose continued development suggests lockdown potential. However, the Steelers still need help at the other cornerback spot, where Donte Jackson has been adequate but not an ideal long-term solution.
Jackson has outperformed Davis in key areas, allowing just 53.1% of passes completed against him and earning an exceptional passer rating of 31.5. If Jackson sustains this level of play, the Steelers are likely to prioritize re-signing him. However, should negotiations fall through, Davis could emerge as a viable fallback option to pair with Porter Jr. in the Steelers’ secondary.
Davis’ experience and adaptability make him an appealing prospect for Pittsburgh. His ability to transition between defensive schemes has been a valuable asset in Detroit, and the Steelers could utilize his versatility in a similar role. While Davis hasn’t lived up to expectations with the Lions, his veteran presence and secondary contributions could align with Pittsburgh’s needs.
Both Detroit and Pittsburgh are projected to have significant salary cap space in the offseason. Over the Cap estimates the Steelers will have $73.4 million available, while the Lions will have $70.1 million. This financial flexibility positions both teams to pursue free-agent moves, including addressing their cornerback situations.
The Steelers’ cornerback plans hinge on negotiations with Jackson, who will be a free agent. If they cannot retain Jackson, Davis could be an affordable and reasonable replacement. The uncertainty surrounding Jackson’s future might push the Steelers to consider Davis to bolster their defensive backfield.
In conclusion, while Davis’ performance with the Lions has been underwhelming, a fresh start with the Steelers could benefit both parties. With ample cap space, Pittsburgh can afford the move, and Davis could bring the experience and adaptability the Steelers need to solidify their secondary for the 2025 season.
