Detroit’s 2024 season ended in bitter disappointment, with their playoff run cut short by a dominant Washington Commanders offense. A key factor in their defensive struggles was the lack of an effective pass rush, which allowed rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels to carve them up. The absence of Aidan Hutchinson due to a season-ending injury only worsened the situation, exposing the team’s lack of depth.
As the Lions head into the 2025 offseason, addressing their edge-rushing concerns has become a priority—especially after releasing Za’Darius Smith. With that in mind, Mason Cameron of Pro Football Focus has suggested a high-profile move: a trade for Kayvon Thibodeaux of the New York Giants.
Could Detroit Pursue Thibodeaux?
Thibodeaux, who was selected three spots after Hutchinson in the 2022 draft, hasn’t quite lived up to the expectations in New York. His highest single-season pass-rush grade from PFF has surpassed 70.0 only once, leading to speculation that a change of scenery could unlock his full potential.
With the Giants facing an impending decision on his fifth-year option and potential extension, they may opt to maximize his trade value while they still can. The Lions, with both the cap space and defensive structure in place, could be an ideal landing spot for the young pass rusher.
Despite battling injuries in 2024, Thibodeaux still managed 5.5 sacks in 12 games. The prior season, he had a breakout performance with 11.5 sacks in 17 games. Pairing him with Hutchinson would give Detroit a formidable pass-rushing duo, potentially unlocking Thibodeaux’s full potential by taking pressure off him.
What Would It Take?
Acquiring Thibodeaux would likely cost at least a Day 2 draft pick, but given his contract situation, Detroit would control his rights for two seasons even without an immediate extension.
However, the biggest hurdle to any potential deal is New York’s reluctance to part with him. With general manager Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll under immense pressure, weakening their defense by trading a key player seems unlikely—at least before the season begins.
That said, if circumstances change and Thibodeaux becomes available later in the offseason or at the trade deadline, Detroit should absolutely explore the opportunity.
