Grade the trade proposal: Lions Potential hypothetical Jameson Williams replacement

While a Williams trade still feels unlikely, it’s hard to ignore the chatter from a trusted national insider. If the Lions were to entertain that idea, they’d undoubtedly have a strategy to fill the gap—either by drafting a receiver early or acquiring one through a trade. There are multiple avenues they could explore in that regard.

One suggestion came from Pro Football Focus analyst Thomas Valentine, who proposed a deal that would help the Lions address the void at the “X” receiver position—a need in their offense with or without Williams.

Proposed Trade:

• Lions receive: WR George Pickens, 2025 sixth-round pick (No. 185)
• Steelers receive: 2025 third-round pick (No. 102), 2025 sixth-round pick (No. 196)

Valentine argues that while Detroit has several areas that could use reinforcements—wide receiver, edge rusher, and offensive guard among them—landing a talented yet inconsistent wideout like Pickens could provide the reliable outside presence they’ve been missing. He notched a 78.6 grade from PFF in 2024 and has flashed WR1 potential.

With Pickens set to hit free agency after 2025 and the Steelers having already made a splash by trading for D.K. Metcalf, it’s plausible they’d be open to moving him for the right return. Pittsburgh has a strong track record of replacing receivers through the draft, often without missing a beat.

Still, Pickens’ time in the league has been uneven. Despite a 1,100-yard season, he’s been criticized for inconsistent play and occasional maturity issues. These concerns may not align with the culture Lions coach Dan Campbell is building, where character and locker-room fit are just as important as raw ability.

Lions GM Brad Holmes has already suggested that future contracts are top of mind, especially with wide receiver salaries skyrocketing. Trading for Pickens would only add to the team’s growing list of extension decisions.

Taking all factors into account—on-field performance, contract status, and culture fit—there are more suitable and stable options available if Detroit does end up replacing Williams.

Final Grade for the Trade Proposal: D