Mark Pope vs. John Calipari: Comparing Their First-Year Success at Kentucky

Did Pope Lay a Strong Foundation for the Future?

When Calipari took over Kentucky in 2009 after a deep tournament run with Memphis, he immediately signed an eight-year deal. His first season (2009-10) was a spectacular one—he led the Wildcats to a 35-3 record, an SEC regular season title, and a conference tournament championship. By contrast, Pope’s first year (2023-24) ended with a 24-12 record—solid, but not extraordinary by Kentucky’s lofty standards.

Pope’s team finished with a 10-8 SEC record and suffered a quarterfinal exit in the conference tournament. Entering the NCAA Tournament as a No. 11 seed (third in the Midwest Region), Kentucky dominated early, easily handling Troy and Illinois while trailing for less than a minute in total. However, their run ended in the Sweet 16 with a 65-78 loss to Tennessee.

On the other hand, Calipari’s first-year squad reached the Elite Eight before falling to West Virginia. Given that his team was a No. 1 seed and had legitimate championship aspirations, their exit may have been a greater disappointment. However, the roster was stacked with elite talent, including top overall recruit John Wall and future NBA stars like DeMarcus Cousins, Eric Bledsoe, and Daniel Orton. Their 14-2 SEC record secured the program’s 44th regular-season conference title.

What’s Next for Kentucky Under Pope?

Unlike Calipari’s powerhouse roster, Pope’s team entered the season without a top ranking or overwhelming expectations. Still, they delivered big wins over Duke in the Champions Classic and defeated archrival Louisville on the road. They also took down Gonzaga, Florida, Mississippi State, Texas A&M, Missouri, and swept Tennessee—making history by tying the school record for the most top-15 wins in a single season.

Injuries were a challenge throughout the year, with Jaxson Robinson (wrist) and Kerr Kriisa (foot) suffering season-ending setbacks, while Lamont Butler (ankle, shoulder) and Andrew Carr (back) missed games at various points. Even with these obstacles, Kentucky secured eight wins over top-15 teams and 12 Quad 1 victories—making Pope’s first season an overall success.

Though he fell three wins short of delivering the program’s ninth national championship, Pope has already shown he can elevate the program. His early success should help him attract top recruits, ensuring that Kentucky remains a powerhouse in the years ahead. Many doubted whether he could lead the Wildcats back to prominence so quickly, but he has already proven he’s up to the challenge.