The Risk of Waiting: Why Delaying Hutchinson's Deal Could Cost Detroit Millions

The Detroit Lions are on the verge of making some tough financial decisions as the franchise’s core begins to blossom into stars. One name at the center of those talks? Aidan Hutchinson. Now entering his third NFL season, Hutchinson is no longer just the local kid with potential—he’s become the face of the Lions’ rising defense and a top-tier edge rusher in the league. But is it time to make him the NFL’s highest-paid defender?

That’s the question now facing the front office—and the fanbase.

Hutchinson, drafted second overall in 2022, has delivered on expectations and then some. He’s racked up 21 career sacks in his first two seasons and added consistent quarterback pressures, earning Pro Bowl recognition and anchoring a Lions defense that has become a cornerstone of the team’s turnaround under Dan Campbell. His relentless motor, versatility, and leadership have made him more than just a pass rusher—he’s a culture-setter in Detroit.

But becoming the highest-paid defender in the NFL is no small feat.

Currently, that title belongs to Nick Bosa, who signed a five-year, $170 million extension with the San Francisco 49ers in 2023, averaging $34 million per year. For Hutchinson to surpass that mark, the Lions would likely need to offer him a deal in the range of $140–160 million over four years—putting his average salary north of $35 million annually.

Some fans believe he’s worth every penny. After all, if Detroit wants to keep their young core intact and send a message to the rest of the league, locking up Hutchinson with a market-setting deal could solidify their identity as a franchise that takes care of its own.

Others urge caution. The Lions already picked up Hutchinson’s fifth-year option for 2026, meaning they still control him for two more seasons. Plus, while he’s been highly productive, he hasn’t quite reached the level of a T.J. Watt or Myles Garrett—yet. Committing top-tier money now could backfire if injuries arise or performance dips.

Still, the argument for paying him early is strong. Waiting often leads to higher costs. Just ask teams like the Cowboys with CeeDee Lamb or the Bengals with Tee Higgins. The edge rusher market will only continue to inflate, and the Lions can benefit from negotiating before Hutchinson’s next breakout campaign.

Dan Campbell and Brad Holmes have been tight-lipped but have emphasized their commitment to building around homegrown talent. And if history is any guide—look at the extensions for Penei Sewell and Amon-Ra St. Brown earlier this year—Detroit won’t hesitate to spend when the time is right.

So we put the question to you:
Should the Detroit Lions make Aidan Hutchinson the highest-paid defender in the NFL?

Vote in our poll and let your voice be heard. This decision could shape the franchise for years to come.

Tags: Aiden Hutchinson